West Central Illinois Brady List

By Benjamin Cox on November 19, 2026 at 11:01am

A new statewide investigation into police credibility has identified several law enforcement officers with ties to West Central Illinois.

The Invisible Institute and Chicago Reader compiled records from prosecutors’ offices across Illinois, identifying more than 580 active officers with potential credibility issues. The records, known as Brady lists, help prosecutors disclose officer misconduct or bias that could affect testimony in criminal cases.

In Brown County, former sheriff’s deputy Cody Shaffer appears on the list. WGEM reported Shaffer’s 2023 arrest for allegedly battering his pregnant girlfriend. Shaffer was convicted of two felony battery charges in Adams County in 2024 and sentenced to four years of probation.

Two Illinois Department of Natural Resources officers associated with Morgan County also appear: Joseph Cochran, listed as inactive, and William Wichern, listed as active.

The investigation specifically identifies Wichern for repeatedly making racist, homophobic, and sexist statements to fellow officers.

Sangamon County Sheriff’s Deputy Travis Koester, who is classified as active, is also among those listed, although the database does not specify a reason. However, a 2024 CBS News investigation documented 13 internal affairs investigations and at least five lawsuits involving Koester over 15 years. Six misconduct complaints were substantiated.

Illinois Times previously reported Koester gave false sworn testimony during a 2010 drug investigation, resulting in a criminal case being dismissed and Koester receiving a written reprimand.

In 2012, two Sangamon County judges questioned Koester’s credibility in separate DUI cases that were subsequently dismissed.

A federal judge also ruled in 2015 that Koester unlawfully arrested a woman and used excessive force by deploying a Taser. Sangamon County settled that lawsuit for 150-thousand dollars.

A separate case involving the detention of a woman whose driver’s license was valid resulted in a 45-thousand-dollar settlement in 2024.

More recently, Koester, president of Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 55, wrote to a judge requesting sentencing leniency for former deputy Sean Grayson, convicted of second-degree murder in the 2024 shooting death of Sonya Massey.

According to Illinois Times, Koester cited inadequate departmental training and Grayson’s cancer diagnosis in seeking leniency. Sangamon County Sheriff Paula Crouch said she was taken aback by the letter, while former Sheriff Jack Campbell publicly disputed Koester’s allegations.

Grayson received the maximum 20-year prison sentence in January and died in custody in August.

An officer’s inclusion on a Brady list does not automatically establish criminal wrongdoing, but the records can affect the officer’s credibility in court.